Whole yellow perch on crushed ice in the boat's tray

Fresh fish

from $1.00/lbOff the boatFlown in daily

Family owned, and the Captain fishes Lake Erie himself — while the lake is fishing, the local half of what’s in is his own catch.
More about the shop

Search what’s in

What's in

Off the Boat · Lake Erie

Perch, walleye and whitefish, the Captain’s own catch, sold while the lake fishes.

Prices move with the catch. Call (814) 520-5047 to hear what's in today.

Yellow Perch fillets$18 / lb
fresh or frozen
What’s in it
Yellow Perch fillets
Per 3 oz cooked · 99 calories
Excellent source of vitamin B121.9 µg · 78% of a day’s value
Figures from the USDA FoodData Central entry for Fish, perch, mixed species, cooked, dry heat. A day’s value is the amount an adult is advised to get, used on every nutrition label.
WalleyeWhole.$4.50 / lb
fresh or frozen
What’s in it
Walleye
Per 3 oz cooked · 101 calories
Excellent source of vitamin B122 µg · 82% of a day’s value
Figures from the USDA FoodData Central entry for Fish, pike, walleye, cooked, dry heat. A day’s value is the amount an adult is advised to get, used on every nutrition label.
CatfishWhole.
What’s in it
Catfish
Per 3 oz cooked · 89 calories
Excellent source of vitamin B122.5 µg · 103% of a day’s value
Figures from the USDA FoodData Central entry for Fish, catfish, channel, wild, cooked, dry heat. A day’s value is the amount an adult is advised to get, used on every nutrition label.

See all 5 in Off the Boat · Lake Erie

Ocean & Gulf

Flown in from the Atlantic, Pacific and Gulf of Mexico.

Octopus$9.50 / lb
Orange Roughy$20 / lb
Haddock$13.50 / lb
Salmon$12.50 / lb
frozen
What’s in it
Salmon
Per 3 oz cooked · 175 calories
1.8 g omega-3
Figures from the USDA FoodData Central entry for Fish, salmon, Atlantic, farmed, cooked, dry heat. A day’s value is the amount an adult is advised to get, used on every nutrition label.
TunaLoin steaks, never frozen.Market
fresh or frozen
What’s in it
Tuna
Per 3 oz cooked · 111 calories
Excellent source of selenium91.8 µg · 167% of a day’s value
Figures from the USDA FoodData Central entry for Fish, tuna, yellowfin, fresh, cooked, dry heat. A day’s value is the amount an adult is advised to get, used on every nutrition label.
Halibut$24 / lb
fresh or frozen
What’s in it
Halibut
Per 3 oz cooked · 94 calories
Excellent source of selenium47.1 µg · 86% of a day’s value
Figures from the USDA FoodData Central entry for Fish, halibut, Atlantic and Pacific, cooked, dry heat. A day’s value is the amount an adult is advised to get, used on every nutrition label.
GrouperMarket
fresh or frozen
What’s in it
Grouper
Per 3 oz cooked · 100 calories
Excellent source of selenium39.8 µg · 72% of a day’s value
Figures from the USDA FoodData Central entry for Fish, grouper, mixed species, cooked, dry heat. A day’s value is the amount an adult is advised to get, used on every nutrition label.
Red SnapperWhole.$12.50 / lb
frozen
What’s in it
Red Snapper
Per 3 oz cooked · 109 calories
Excellent source of vitamin B123 µg · 124% of a day’s value
Figures from the USDA FoodData Central entry for Fish, snapper, mixed species, cooked, dry heat. A day’s value is the amount an adult is advised to get, used on every nutrition label.
MackerelWhole.$7 / lb
What’s in it
Mackerel
Per 3 oz cooked · 223 calories
1 g omega-3
Figures from the USDA FoodData Central entry for Fish, mackerel, Atlantic, cooked, dry heat. A day’s value is the amount an adult is advised to get, used on every nutrition label.
SharkMarket
frozen

See all 19 in Ocean & Gulf

Shellfish

From oysters to lobster, by the pound or the dozen.

Lump Blue Crab Meat$35 / lb
Maine LobsterClaw and knuckle meat. Small and large tubs.$55 / lb
Dry Sea ScallopsCanada.$19.50 / lb
Wild Gulf Shrimp26/30 count.$12.50 / lb
Wild Gulf Shrimp16/20 count.$14 / lb
Tiger Shrimp21/25 count.$11 / lb
Tiger Shrimp8/12 count.$18 / lb
Shucked Oysters$22 / lb
Sea ScallopsMarket
fresh or frozen
What’s in it
Sea Scallops
Per 3 oz cooked · 94 calories
Excellent source of vitamin B121.8 µg · 76% of a day’s value
Figures from the USDA FoodData Central entry for Mollusks, scallop, (bay and sea), cooked, steamed. A day’s value is the amount an adult is advised to get, used on every nutrition label.
Oysters$1.25 / ea
fresh or frozen
What’s in it
Oysters
Per 3 oz cooked · 67 calories
Excellent source of zinc51.9 mg · 471% of a day’s value
Figures from the USDA FoodData Central entry for Mollusks, oyster, eastern, wild, cooked, dry heat. A day’s value is the amount an adult is advised to get, used on every nutrition label.
ClamsCountnecks.$0.50 / ea
fresh or frozen
What’s in it
Clams
Per 3 oz cooked · 126 calories
Excellent source of vitamin B1284.1 µg · 3503% of a day’s value
Figures from the USDA FoodData Central entry for Mollusks, clam, mixed species, cooked, moist heat. A day’s value is the amount an adult is advised to get, used on every nutrition label.
LobsterMarket
fresh
What’s in it
Lobster
Per 3 oz cooked · 76 calories
Excellent source of copper1.3 mg · 146% of a day’s value
Figures from the USDA FoodData Central entry for Crustaceans, lobster, northern, cooked, moist heat. A day’s value is the amount an adult is advised to get, used on every nutrition label.
Snow CrabThree sizes to pick from.Market
frozen
What’s in it
Snow Crab
Per 3 oz cooked · 98 calories
Excellent source of vitamin B128.8 µg · 368% of a day’s value
Figures from the USDA FoodData Central entry for Crustaceans, crab, queen, cooked, moist heat. A day’s value is the amount an adult is advised to get, used on every nutrition label.
King Crab legsMarket
What’s in it
King Crab legs
Per 3 oz cooked · 82 calories
Excellent source of vitamin B129.8 µg · 407% of a day’s value
Figures from the USDA FoodData Central entry for Crustaceans, crab, alaska king, cooked, moist heat. A day’s value is the amount an adult is advised to get, used on every nutrition label.
Blue CrabMarket
fresh
What’s in it
Blue Crab
Per 3 oz cooked · 71 calories
Excellent source of vitamin B122.8 µg · 118% of a day’s value
Figures from the USDA FoodData Central entry for Crustaceans, crab, blue, cooked, moist heat. A day’s value is the amount an adult is advised to get, used on every nutrition label.
CrawfishCooked, unseasoned.$8 / lb
fresh
What’s in it
Crawfish
Per 3 oz cooked · 70 calories
Excellent source of vitamin B121.8 µg · 76% of a day’s value
Figures from the USDA FoodData Central entry for Crustaceans, crayfish, mixed species, wild, cooked, moist heat. A day’s value is the amount an adult is advised to get, used on every nutrition label.

See all 18 in Shellfish

Also in the shop

The rest of the counters

However you want it

Whole or processed, packed for the drive home, or hot from the takeout counter. Just ask.

The other half of the name

It says Fish & Farm for a reason.

The Farm half of the name is a real counter, not a flourish — the shop announced it themselves: “The Farm part of Presque Isle Fish & Farm is finally here.”

Grown here

Local produce alongside the fish, in season.

Sweet cornMcNulty’s, by the dozen, while it runs
TomatoesLocally grown
PotatoesLocally grown
ZucchiniLocally grown
PeppersLocally grown
Green beansLocally grown
GarlicLocally grown
Apple ciderBy the jug, in season

For your own catch

The shelf for hunters and home smokers.

Cures and seasoningsPriced on the shelf
Breading and fry mixesPriced on the shelf

Also here

Smoked and brined here — Whitefish, salmon, brisket, corned beef and pastrami
Live fish — Tanks in the shop
Shop tours — Scheduled through the season — call to ask
Wholesale — The same boat supplies restaurants and retailers

(814) 520-5047

The kitchen

Lunch and dinner, cooked to order.

The kitchen runs Wednesday – Saturday · 11 AM – 5 PM — a shorter window than the shop, so come before five.

Takeout menu

Orders in store preferred. Phone orders include a 5% fee and are prepaid.

Sandwiches

Perch$10
Pollock$10
Shrimp Po Boy$12
Haddock$14
Grouper$12

Fried fish

Yellow Perch (6)$14
Alaskan Pollock (3)$12
Battered Haddock$12
Cod Cakes (2)$8
Grouper (2)$14
Shrimp (8)$8
Coconut Shrimp (8)$8

Sides

Hushpuppies (8)$6
Corn Fritters (8)$4
French Fries$4
Coleslaw (3 oz)$0.50
Bayou Beans$4
Lobster Mac$6

Baskets & plates

Captain's Basket4 battered pollock, 6 hush puppies, fries, slaw, cocktail and tartar$18
Fisherman's BasketHaddock, clam strips, 4 breaded shrimp, french fries, slaw and tartar$24
Perch Meal for Two6 perch, french fries, bayou beans, lobster mac, slaw and tartar$40

Seafood boils

Prepayment required. Boils come prepared with lemon, orange, their signature spice and butter garlic sauce.

Party · 4–6 adults5 lb small red potatoes, 2 lb housemade sausage, 12 corn cobettes, 2 lb shell-on shrimp, 3 large snow crab clusters$85
Family · 3–4 adults2 lb small red potatoes, 1 lb housemade sausage, 6 corn cobettes, 1 lb shell-on shrimp, 2 large snow crab clusters$65
Couples · 2 adults1 lb small red potatoes, ½ lb housemade sausage, 2 corn cobettes, 12 shell-on shrimp, 1 large snow crab cluster$45

Add to any boil

1 lb shrimp$12
2 lg snow crab$18
Lobster tailMarket
1 lb crawfish$8
1 lb clams$10
1 lb mussels$8
1 lb scallopsMarket
1 lb walleye cheeks$24
1 lb frog legs$12
6 corn$3
2 lb potatoes$2
1 lb gator sausage$20
1 lb swordfish sausage$20
1 lb house sausage$8

DIY kits available — ask about supplying all your seafood boil needs. Equipment rental available.

Call (814) 520-5047 to order

Visit

On W 8th, by the Peninsula.

(814) 520-5047

2769 W 8th St, Erie, PA 16505

Sunday – Tuesday	Closed
Wednesday & Thursday	9:00 AM – 5:30 PM
Friday	9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Saturday	9:00 AM – 5:30 PM

Call ahead for today’s catch and holiday hours.

Get directions Facebook Instagram

Off the Boat · Lake Erie

Yellow Perch fillets

Walleye

Catfish

Ocean & Gulf

Salmon

Tuna

Halibut

Grouper

Red Snapper

Mackerel

Shellfish

Sea Scallops

Oysters

Clams

Lobster

Snow Crab

King Crab legs

Blue Crab

Crawfish

The rest of the counters

Soups & Chowders

Smoked & Prepared

The Meat Counter

Frozen Fish

Frozen Seafood & Meals

Spices & Seasonings

Pantry

The Farm

Drinks