Presque Isle Fish & Farm compass-rose roundel
Yellow perch packed in ice, fresh off Lake Erie

Presque Isle Fish & Farm — fresh fish market, takeout kitchen and farm counter on W 8th St, Erie

Family owned, and the Captain fishes Lake Erie himself — while the lake is fishing, the local half of what’s in is our own catch.

Learn more

What's in

Off the Boat · Lake Erie

Perch, walleye and whitefish, the Captain’s own catch, sold while the lake fishes.

Prices move with the catch. Call (814) 520-5047 to hear what's in today.

  • Walleye Cheeks
    Walleye Cheeks$22 / lb
    fresh or frozen
  • Yellow Perch fillets
    Yellow Perch fillets$18 / lb
    fresh or frozen

    What’s in it

    Yellow Perch fillets

    Per 3 oz cooked · 99 calories

    Excellent source of vitamin B121.9 µg · 78% of a day’s value

    Figures from the USDA FoodData Central entry for Fish, perch, mixed species, cooked, dry heat. A day’s value is the amount an adult is advised to get, used on every nutrition label.

  • Walleye Fillets
    Walleye Fillets$18 / lb
    fresh
See all 8 in Off the Boat · Lake Erie

Ocean & Gulf

Flown in from the Atlantic, Pacific and Gulf of Mexico.

  • Orange Roughy
    Orange Roughy$20 / lb
  • Cod
    Cod$14 / lb
  • Haddock
    Haddock$13.50 / lb
  • Florida Grouper
    Florida Grouper$20 / lb
  • Halibut
    Halibut$24 / lb
    fresh or frozen

    What’s in it

    Halibut

    Per 3 oz cooked · 94 calories

    Excellent source of selenium47.1 µg · 86% of a day’s value

    Figures from the USDA FoodData Central entry for Fish, halibut, Atlantic and Pacific, cooked, dry heat. A day’s value is the amount an adult is advised to get, used on every nutrition label.

  • Swordfish
    SwordfishNorth Atlantic.$16 / lb
  • Red Snapper Fillets
    Red Snapper Fillets$20 / lb
See all 37 in Ocean & Gulf

Shellfish

From oysters to lobster, by the pound or the dozen.

  • Maine Lobster
    Maine LobsterClaw and knuckle meat. Small and large tubs.$55 / lb
  • Dry Sea Scallops
    Dry Sea ScallopsCanada.$19.50 / lb
  • Wild Gulf Shrimp
    Wild Gulf Shrimp26/30 count · 16/20 count$12.50–$14 / lb
  • Tiger Shrimp
    Tiger Shrimp21/25 count · 16/20 count · 8/12 count$11–$18 / lb
  • Shucked Oysters
    Shucked Oysters$22 / lb
  • Oysters
    OystersDuxbury.$1.25 / ea
    fresh or frozen

    What’s in it

    Oysters

    Per 3 oz cooked · 67 calories

    Excellent source of zinc51.9 mg · 471% of a day’s value

    Figures from the USDA FoodData Central entry for Mollusks, oyster, eastern, wild, cooked, dry heat. A day’s value is the amount an adult is advised to get, used on every nutrition label.

  • Clams
    ClamsCountnecks.$0.50 / ea
    fresh or frozen

    What’s in it

    Clams

    Per 3 oz cooked · 126 calories

    Excellent source of vitamin B1284.1 µg · 3503% of a day’s value

    Figures from the USDA FoodData Central entry for Mollusks, clam, mixed species, cooked, moist heat. A day’s value is the amount an adult is advised to get, used on every nutrition label.

  • Dry Bay Scallops
    Dry Bay ScallopsSmaller meats than sea scallops.
  • Fresh Calamari
    Fresh CalamariTubes and tentacles.$9 / lb
See all 22 in Shellfish

Also in the shop

The rest of the counters

However you want it

Whole or processed, packed for the drive home, or hot from the takeout counter. Just ask.

The other half of the name

It says Fish & Farm for a reason.

The Farm part of Presque Isle Fish & Farm is finally here. Produce, an in-house deli and smokehouse, and the shelf of kits for your own game.

For your own catch

The shelf for hunters and home smokers.

Breadings and batters

The bags, by the bay.

Andy's Fish Breading, Cajun
Andy's Fish Breading, Cajun
Andy's Fish Breading, Red
Andy's Fish Breading, Red
Andy's Golden Fish Batter
Andy's Golden Fish Batter
Wholey calamari breading
Wholey calamari breading

Boxed mixes

One box, one dinner.

Shore Lunch, Original Recipe
Shore Lunch, Original Recipe
Shore Lunch, Cajun Style
Shore Lunch, Cajun Style
Shore Lunch, Beer Batter
Shore Lunch, Beer Batter
Slap Ya Mama Cajun Fish Fry
Slap Ya Mama Cajun Fish Fry

Rubs and shakers

Con Yeager, by the jar.

Lemon Pepper Seasoning
Lemon Pepper Seasoning
Smokehouse Bar-B-Que Rub
Smokehouse Bar-B-Que Rub
Garlic Pepper Seasoning
Garlic Pepper Seasoning
Mojito Lime Seasoning
Mojito Lime Seasoning

In the shrink wrap

The first three are our own, weighed and wrapped in the shop.

Presque Isle Bay Spice
Presque Isle Bay Spice
Piff breading
Piff breading
Piff seafood boil spice
Piff seafood boil spice
Con Yeager Chili Seasoning
Con Yeager Chili Seasoning

Also here

  • Smoked and brined here — Whitefish, salmon, brisket, corned beef and pastrami
  • Live fish — Tanks in the shop
  • Shop tours — Scheduled through the season — call to ask
  • Wholesale — The same boat supplies restaurants and retailers
(814) 520-5047

The kitchen

Lunch and dinner, cooked to order.

The kitchen runs Wednesday – Saturday · 11 AM – 5 PM — a shorter window than the shop, so come before five.

Takeout menu

Orders in store preferred. Phone orders include a 5% fee and are prepaid.

Sandwiches

  • Perch$10
  • Pollock$10
  • Shrimp Po Boy$12
  • Haddock$14
  • Grouper$12

Fried fish

  • Yellow Perch (6)$14
  • Alaskan Pollock (3)$12
  • Battered Haddock$12
  • Cod Cakes (2)$8
  • Grouper (2)$14
  • Shrimp (8)$8
  • Coconut Shrimp (8)$8

Sides

  • Hushpuppies (8)$6
  • Corn Fritters (8)$4
  • French Fries$4
  • Coleslaw (3 oz)$0.50
  • Bayou Beans$4
  • Lobster Mac$6

Baskets & plates

  • Captain's Basket
    Captain's Basket4 battered pollock, 6 hush puppies, fries, slaw, cocktail and tartar$18
  • Fisherman's Basket
    Fisherman's BasketHaddock, clam strips, 4 breaded shrimp, french fries, slaw and tartar$24
  • Perch Meal for Two
    Perch Meal for Two6 perch, french fries, bayou beans, lobster mac, slaw and tartar$40

Seafood boils

Prepayment required. Boils come prepared with lemon, orange, our signature spice and butter garlic sauce.

  • Party · 4–6 adults
    Party · 4–6 adults5 lb small red potatoes, 2 lb housemade sausage, 12 corn cobettes, 2 lb shell-on shrimp, 3 large snow crab clusters$85
  • Family · 3–4 adults
    Family · 3–4 adults2 lb small red potatoes, 1 lb housemade sausage, 6 corn cobettes, 1 lb shell-on shrimp, 2 large snow crab clusters$65
  • Couples · 2 adults
    Couples · 2 adults1 lb small red potatoes, ½ lb housemade sausage, 2 corn cobettes, 12 shell-on shrimp, 1 large snow crab cluster$45

Add to any boil

  • 1 lb shrimp$12
  • 2 lg snow crab$18
  • Lobster tailMarket
  • 1 lb crawfish$8
  • 1 lb clams$10
  • 1 lb mussels$8
  • 1 lb scallopsMarket
  • 1 lb walleye cheeks$24
  • 1 lb frog legs$12
  • 6 corn$3
  • 2 lb potatoes$2
  • 1 lb gator sausage$20
  • 1 lb swordfish sausage$20
  • 1 lb house sausage$8

DIY kits available — ask about supplying all your seafood boil needs. Equipment rental available.

Call (814) 520-5047 to order

Visit

On W 8th, by the Peninsula.

(814) 520-5047

2769 W 8th St, Erie, PA 16505

Sunday – TuesdayClosed
Wednesday & Thursday9:00 AM – 5:30 PM
Friday9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Saturday9:00 AM – 5:30 PM

Call ahead for today’s catch and holiday hours.

Get directionsFacebookInstagram